Opening Quotes
“He who truly knows has no occasion to shout.” – Leonardo da Vinci
“A person is bound to lose when he talks about himself; if he belittles himself, he is believed; if he praises himself, he isn’t believed.” – Michel de Montaigne
“A session of boasting won’t attract any real friends. It will set you up on a pedestal, however, making you a clearer target.” – Richelle E. Goodrich
“If I seem to boast more than is becoming, my excuse is that I brag for humanity rather than for myself.” – Henry David Thoreau
“If I cannot brag of knowing something, then I brag of not knowing it; at any rate, brag.” – Ralph Waldo Emerson
“Creative people are humble and proud at the same time. It is remarkable to meet a famous person who you expect to be arrogant or supercilious, only to encounter self-deprecation and shyness instead. Yet there are good reasons why this should be so. These individuals are well aware that they stand, in Newton’s words, ‘on the shoulders of giants.’ Their respect for the area in which they work makes them aware of the long line of previous contributions to it, putting their own in perspective. They’re also aware of the role that luck played in their own achievements. And they’re usually so focused on future projects and current challenges that past accomplishments, no matter how outstanding, are no longer very interesting to them. At the same time, they know that in comparison with others, they have accomplished a great deal. And this knowledge provides a sense of security, even pride.” – Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi
A Common Concern
Understanding the difference between arrogance and confidence is essential not just for how others perceive us, but for how we navigate our own abilities, relationships, and sense of self-worth.
One common concern I see in highly accomplished individuals is a social fear of appearing arrogant. Many worry that showing pride in their abilities or accomplishments will make others think they’re full of themselves.
At the same time, these people often struggle to tolerate peers who seem openly boastful: “Why on earth do they brag so much? I can do that too, and I’m not drawing attention to myself… What’s the deal?”
The reality is that confidence and arrogance are not the same thing. Truly confident individuals can acknowledge their accomplishments without playing status games meant to diminish others.
As Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi notes, creative people are often both humble and proud. They recognize their achievements, yet understand the role of luck, effort, and those who came before them. Their focus tends to be on future projects rather than past accolades.
Understanding Pride, Hubris, and Humility
“True humility is not thinking less of yourself; it is thinking of yourself less.” – C.S. Lewis
Pride is a deep feeling of satisfaction in our own achievements, the accomplishments of people we care about, or qualities and possessions that are widely admired.
Hubris, in contrast, is excessive pride or overconfidence – a desire to dominate or assert superiority over others.
Humility is the ability to accurately recognize our contributions while acknowledging our strengths, imperfections, and opportunities for growth.
A Fun Activity
In my lessons, I explore research on each of these above concepts to help students build a framework for understanding themselves and navigating social interactions in a healthy, confident way.
When teaching this concept in a group setting, I often use real quotes from social media and have students sort them into “arrogant” versus “confident” categories. Everyone gets to share their opinions, and it’s always interesting. No one agrees on everything! It makes for a lively and fun discussion.
Here are a few additional quotes to consider:
- “It’s hard to be humble, when you’re as great as I am.” – Muhammad Ali
- “Haters are just confused admirers.” – Justin Bieber
Are these statements arrogant, confident, or somewhere in between? What do you think?
Journal/Reflection Questions
- Is it possible for someone to be too humble? Why might that be a problem?
- How do you react when people disagree with you? What does “arrogance vs. confidence” have to do with perspective-taking? Can you see the other person’s side?
- How do you handle losing? How do you handle winning?
- Who’s the most confident person you know? Who’s the most arrogant person you know? Do you think mutual acquaintances would agree?
- Why do some people accomplish a lot and become arrogant while other people accomplish a lot and become humble?
Go Deeper/Resources
https://greatergood.berkeley.edu/article/item/what_does_intellectual_humility_look_like
https://humilityandconviction.uconn.edu/blank/what-is-intellectual-humility/
Posted in Social Cognition, Social and Emotional Learning


Classes
Blog posts often have a corresponding class or workshop.
Subscribe
Subscribe to the blog for interesting information about cognitive diversity from Michelle’s research and classes.
Related Posts
Self-Disclosure: A Guide for Deep Thinkers
Posted in Social Cognition, Social and Emotional Learning
Research suggests that many high-ability learners, even those who feel confident in their abilities and academic strengths, tend to share less about themselves with others. In a study …
Handling Constructive Criticism
Posted in Social Cognition, Social and Emotional Learning
Opening Quotes “Sometimes when you innovate, you make mistakes. It is best to admit them quickly, and get on with improving your other innovations.” – Steve Jobs “The …