Guiding Question (from a parent): Regarding identity, what makes for a healthier/safer/more stable sense of identity than one’s rare abilities?
A healthier, more stable sense of identity is often built on being a whole person – someone who exists beyond their abilities, even while living in a fast-moving brain that often feels wired to push, question, or achieve.
Talents and intelligence may shape a high achieving person’s experience, but they are not the foundation of worth. True identity is rooted in something deeper. It’s a quiet but profound truth that a person’s value does not depend on what they can do, how they think, or how unique they are. We easily recognize the inherent worth of a pet or a plant and value it simply because it exists. People are no different. Human worth is intrinsic, not earned.
Giftedness and creativity are just some traits among many. Like all traits, they brings strengths and struggles, advantages and unexpected hurdles. It’s part of the landscape, not the whole story. A more grounded identity comes from recognizing this – and building a life defined not by exceptionality, but by purpose, integrity, curiosity, connection, and living intentionally. Or, to put it simply: giftedness may shape your life, but it doesn’t have to define it.
“I Am… a Lot of Things” Exercise
A powerful way to help children (and even adults) develop a more grounded and resilient sense of identity is to intentionally reflect on who they are beyond their abilities. In The Gifted Kids Workbook by Heather Boorman, one simple yet meaningful exercise invites participants to finish the sentence “I am…” as many times as they can. Responses can include personality traits (e.g., fun-loving, curious, honest), roles (e.g., sibling, teammate, friend), values (e.g., kind, thoughtful, resilient), and anything else that comes to mind (e.g. pet owner, bird watcher, beach comber).
The purpose of this exercise is to expand a person’s understanding of their identity and to help them see they are made up of far more than just intelligence, performance, or potential. It also helps highlight how much they contribute to the world and to the people around them just by being who they are.
After completing the list, take a moment to read it over and notice the range of qualities that define you. You might be surprised at just how many meaningful, valuable aspects make up your whole self – many of which may have nothing to do with giftedness at all.
This kind of reflection can be especially helpful for gifted children who sometimes feel defined by their abilities or who internalize the idea that their worth depends on achievement.
“I Am… Wearing a Lot of Hats” Exercise
I like to expand on the “I am…” exercise from The Gifted Kids Workbook. Many of my clients know I love quirky history facts, so let’s consider it from this angle.
For centuries, hats weren’t just practical. They were deeply symbolic. Across cultures, headwear indicated identity, profession, status, or belonging – think crowns for royalty, miters for bishops, or specific caps for military ranks. By the mid-19th century, even more everyday professions had their own signature hats – top hats for the wealthy, bowler hats for bankers, or newsboy caps for working-class youth.
Eventually, as hats faded from daily fashion, the idea of “wearing different hats” shifted from literal to metaphorical. Today, we use the phrase to describe how we take on different roles and responsibilities in our lives—student, sibling, artist, problem-solver, friend.
When we name the hats we wear, we begin to see how rich and varied our identity truly is – how we’re more than just our intellect or abilities. Each role adds dimension and depth to who we are, reminding us that a full life isn’t always about doing one thing exceptionally – it’s about showing up fully in all the different parts of ourselves.
Optional Journal/Discussion Questions
- How many “hats” do you wear in life? Think back to our historical exploration of the expression “some people wear a lot of hats.”
- Where do you place most of your identity (the hat you are most proud of or wear the most)?
- What would happen if you “lost” that hat?
- Now imagine you are juggling all of your hats. As a juggler, you can drop one or two hats and pick them up later (your identity as a runner, being in choir, a hobby, etc.). But maybe you have a glass ball in with your hats (the glass ball is your mental health). Try not to drop the glass ball.
Go Deeper/Resources
-The coat of arms activity from Activity 27 in The Gifted Kids Workbook by Heather Boorman


Classes
Blog posts often have a corresponding class or workshop.
Subscribe
Subscribe to the blog for interesting information about cognitive diversity from Michelle’s research and classes.
Related Posts
Self-Disclosure: A Guide for Deep Thinkers
Posted in Social Cognition, Social and Emotional Learning
Research suggests that many high-ability learners, even those who feel confident in their abilities and academic strengths, tend to share less about themselves with others. In a study …
Handling Constructive Criticism
Posted in Social Cognition, Social and Emotional Learning
Opening Quotes “Sometimes when you innovate, you make mistakes. It is best to admit them quickly, and get on with improving your other innovations.” – Steve Jobs “The …