Opening Quotes

“To be effective, learning needs to be effortful. That’s not to say that anything that makes learning easier is counterproductive or that all unpleasant learning is effective. The key here is desirable difficulty. The same way you feel a muscle ‘burn’ when it’s being strengthened, the brain needs to feel some discomfort when it’s learning. Your mind might hurt for a while, but that’s a good thing.” – Mary Slaughter and David Rock with the NeuroLeadership in Fast Company

“Being confused is an exercise.” – John Frusciante

Opening Definitions

Learning refers to the process of acquiring new knowledge, skills, or behaviors through experience. It is an ongoing, dynamic process where understanding deepens over time through practice, reflection, and adaptation. Learning involves curiosity, exploration, and the ability to adapt to new information or challenges.

Knowing, on the other hand, refers to the state of having acquired and internalized knowledge or facts. It is the result of learning and represents understanding or certainty about something. Knowing is more static—it’s having information at your disposal that you can recall or apply.

Zone of Optimal Confusion

Learning and knowing are not the same thing, and true learning is designed to be hard, regardless of high ability. Learning is the continuous process of effort, discovery, and growth, while knowing is the result of that process – having established facts, skills, or insights that you can confidently access. 

This distinction can be difficult for some talented individuals to grasp because of their natural ability to quickly acquire knowledge and demonstrate proficiency in certain areas (usually areas they are passionate about).

They often experience a strong sense of “knowing” before they’ve fully engaged in the deeper process of learning. This can create a misconception that learning should always be easy and immediate, leading to frustration when they encounter challenges or things they don’t instantly understand.

When Previous Methods Breakdown

Some students develop coping mechanisms early in life that allow them to excel with minimal effort. Used to relying on their ability to grasp concepts quickly without needing to engage in the struggle that comes with deeper learning, they may feel disoriented or discouraged when faced with a subject or skill that requires more time, effort, or even outright failure (which can be involved in the creative process).

The discomfort of grappling with something unfamiliar or difficult can be perceived as a sign of inadequacy, even though it’s a normal part of the learning process. In essence, the difference between learning and knowing might be less obvious for certain individuals, especially if they’ve spent much of their academic careers relying on their ability to memorize, recall information quickly, or do a quick creative workaround.

The Role of Identity

Many high ability students are accustomed to being seen as “experts” or “quick learners,” which can make the process of “true learning” – which often involves trial and error, setbacks, and the need for persistence – feel like a challenge to their identity or self-worth. They may resist stepping into a “beginner’s mindset,” because it contradicts their perception of themselves as “someone who should already know.” Clinging to an old identity creates an additional layer of complexity.

Mindset Shift Needed

Ultimately, for gifted students, the journey from knowing to learning requires a shift in mindset: from seeing intelligence as a static trait to recognizing that real intellectual growth comes from embracing challenges, asking questions, and engaging in the uncomfortable process of not knowing.

This involves building a tolerance for tasks that don’t have immediate resolution, accepting uncertainty, and tolerating ambiguity.

What Happens When Things Get Too Confusing?

Sometimes, when things get really confusing, it’s easy to feel stuck. Based on research, here’s what can happen when confusion takes over:

  • Frustration: When you can’t make sense of something, it can be frustrating and make you want to give up.
  • Disengagement: When confusion drags on, you may lose interest and stop paying attention.
  • Boredom: If things don’t make sense and you don’t know how to fix it, you might start feeling bored or distracted.

But don’t worry! There are ways to handle confusion and stay on track. Some strategies to help you get unstuck include:

  • Ask for Help: Don’t be afraid to reach out to a teacher, classmate, or even online resources to clear things up.
  • Find the Key Information: Look for the most important points to focus on and break things down step-by-step.
  • Monitor Your Progress: Check how far you’ve come and see if you’re understanding the material as you go.
  • Plan a New Strategy: If one way isn’t working, try thinking of a different approach to tackle the problem.

Confusion is a normal part of learning – it’s all about using the right strategies to work through it.

Optional Journal/Discussion Prompts

  1. What is one of your more difficult subjects or classes? If you don’t have any currently, can you think of some from the past? If you can’t think of an area academically, what about a sport, cooking, art, or riding a bike?
  2. What type of “self-talk” would be helpful while trying something new or difficult? Do you have examples of beneficial thought processes that help people do hard things? (This is why I use quotes a lot in my classes.)
  3. What emotions do you have as you imagine working on this activity (from question 1)? What does your mind tell you about yourself or the activity?
  4. List 5 things that are hard for you (or will be hard for you someday – completing a certain class, running a marathon, writing a research book, graduating early). Commit to learning/achieving at least one of them. What strategies will you use to tolerate and overcome confusion?

Go Deeper/Resources

For kids: Activity 12 From “The Gifted Kids Workbook” by Heather Boorman

For adults: https://brenebrown.com/book/atlas-of-the-heart/



Classes

Blog posts often have a corresponding class or workshop.

Subscribe

Subscribe to the blog for interesting information about cognitive diversity from Michelle’s research and classes.

Loading

Related Posts

Analogous Thinking

At its core, analogical thinking is one of the most powerful tools for creative problem solving. What Is Analogical Thinking? Analogical thinking is the ability to use knowledge …

Handling Multipotentiality: Are You Passionate and/or Good at Several Things?

Guiding Questions What is multipotentiality and what does it have to do with high achievement? In what ways is multipotentiality like having a large menu to choose from, …