Acquire the habit of attending carefully to what is being said by another, and to entering, as far as possible, into the mind of the speaker. – Marcus Aurelius
Opening Story: “Twin Speak”
One of my best friends is a twin. When she was little, she and her sister invented their own secret way of talking. It was a made-up language only the two of them could understand. This kind of thing is actually pretty common among twins, and they call it “Twin Speak.”
To them, it wasn’t gibberish. It was natural. It worked.
When they started school, the adults around them grew concerned. My friend was referred to speech therapy because something was “wrong.” She wasn’t developing language in the “right” way, and she felt bad about it. That being said, she only communicated differently around her sister. She communicated “normally” with others.
Let’s pause for a moment.
These twins had created their own symbol system of communication (this takes some mental prowess!), and it was one that fit their brains and their bond. It was a real, meaningful connection. And yet, instead of being recognized as creative or flexible, it was a problem to be corrected.
What if the issue wasn’t the twins’ language at all, but the fact it didn’t match what society expected?
This story might seem unique, but it actually points to something much bigger about how we understand – or misunderstand – one another. Especially when we communicate in ways that are different from what most people expect.
The Double Empathy Problem
This brings us to something called the Double Empathy Problem. It’s a powerful idea with a lot to offer anyone who has ever felt misunderstood, left out, or frustrated trying to connect with others. This can be especially true for people who think, feel, or communicate in ways that aren’t “typical.” This might include autistic people, people with learning differences, ADHD, profoundly gifted individuals, or even just people with quiet voices.
Communication Preferences: Everyone Has Them
Let’s start by thinking about what communication really means. We often hear it’s about talking, listening, making eye contact, and using the “right” facial expressions. But communication is really about connection. It’s how we share ideas, feelings, and information with each other.
Just like people have favorite foods, favorite colors, or favorite ways to learn, we all have communication preferences too.
Some people love fast-paced back-and-forth conversations. Others like to take time to think before responding. Some people express their feelings through words, while others might show them through art, movement, or even silence. None of these ways are “better” or “worse.” They’re just different.
Love Languages?
When I first heard about communication preferences, they reminded me of love languages – the idea that people show and feel love in different ways, like giving gifts, spending time together, or offering words of encouragement. It’s a reminder that even people who care deeply about each other can “speak” different emotional languages and that’s okay.
But here’s the problem: society tends to treat one style of communication – usually the one most common in neurotypical people – as the “right” way. Everyone else is expected to adjust. And when they don’t, they’re often labeled as awkward, rude, uncooperative, or disordered.
This is where the Double Empathy Problem begins to unfold.
What Is the Double Empathy Problem?
For a long time, many researchers assumed that autistic people (and by extension, other neurodivergent people) just weren’t good at social skills – they lacked empathy or couldn’t read social cues. But a researcher named Dr. Damian Milton challenged that idea in 2012 with something called the Double Empathy Problem.
His theory said: Maybe it’s not that one person is bad at communication. Maybe it’s that two people with very different ways of thinking and feeling are having a hard time understanding each other. It’s not a one-way problem. It’s mutual.
Information Chains: How Messages Get Lost
One cool way scientists have studied the Double Empathy Problem is by looking at something called information chains.
Many of the Davidson Young Scholar students I work with play Gartic Phone during some of our Friday group sessions. Most would agree – it’s often hilarious. I like to remind them that it’s really just a digital version of the old game Telephone.
Imagine this: a group of people sit in a circle. One person is told a story. They whisper it to the next person, who whispers it to the next, and so on. At the end, the last person tries to repeat the story out loud.
Researchers used this kind of experiment to see how well information travels between people of the same or different neurotypes. They found something really interesting:
- When all the people were neurotypical (non-autistic), the story passed along pretty well.
- When all the people were autistic, the story also passed along well – just as well as in the all-neurotypical group.
- But when the group was mixed – some autistic, some non-autistic – a lot more details were lost. The message changed. Misunderstandings grew. People felt less connected.
This shows that communication between similar neurotypes tends to flow more smoothly, not because one group is better, but because they share common styles, assumptions, and rhythms. In mixed groups, those differences can cause the message to break down.
It’s not that people aren’t trying. It’s that their ways of understanding don’t quite match.
You’re on My Wavelength
“You’re on my wavelength,” is a common idiom used to describe a sense of mutual understanding – when two people “get” each other, communicate easily, or think in similar ways.
Think of it like trying to tune a radio: If you’re on different wavelengths, it’s hard to hear each other clearly. That doesn’t mean either radio is broken. It just means they’re not set to the same frequency.
The Double Empathy Problem shows us that communication struggles often come from a mismatch, not a “deficit.” And that’s a big deal. Because when we believe people have deficits, we try to fix them. But if we realize it’s a mismatch, we can start looking for connection points instead.
What This Means on a Bigger Scale
For decades, society has treated communication differences as something to “fix.” Neurodivergent people, especially autistic individuals, have been taught to “act normal,” make eye contact, smile the right way, respond “appropriately,” and hide behaviors that seem different.
But if the Double Empathy Problem is true, and research says it is, then this approach is not only unfair, it’s also unscientific. It’s based on an outdated idea that one way of communicating is “correct” and everyone else is just doing it wrong.
New studies show that neurodivergent people, when interacting with others who understand their style, feel more relaxed, successful, and understood. They don’t need to mask who they are. In my own experience working with profoundly gifted and neurodivergent people, I’ve seen firsthand how clearly and effectively they communicate when they’re in an environment that values their way of connecting.
Here’s what this teaches us: When someone struggles to connect, it doesn’t always mean they’re doing something wrong. It might mean that they and the other person aren’t speaking the same “language” yet. And instead of pushing one person to change, maybe wisdom is the ability to sometimes meet in the middle.
Empathy: Interpreting the Feelings of Others
Let’s talk about empathy (the ability to understand or share how someone else is feeling). Maybe you’ve heard that word a lot. Maybe you’ve even been told to “have more empathy” or that someone else “lacks empathy.” But here’s the thing: empathy is more complex than most people realize.
There are actually different types of empathy:
- Emotional empathy is when you feel what someone else is feeling – like crying when your friend is sad, or laughing when someone else is happy.
- Cognitive empathy is when you can understand what someone is feeling and why – like knowing that your friend is upset because their cat died, even if they’re not saying much.
Research shows many neurodivergent people, specifically autistic individuals, may actually feel emotional empathy very deeply. Sometimes, they feel it so deeply it overwhelms them (empathic hyperarousal). But at the same time, they might struggle with cognitive empathy, especially when someone communicates feelings in subtle or indirect ways.
Let’s think about what that means: A person might care deeply, but still not know how to show it in a way others expect. Or they might not realize someone else is upset because the signs are hard to read.
This can lead to misunderstandings. Someone might assume, “You don’t care about me,” when really, the other person is just overwhelmed or unsure how to respond.
This goes both ways. Non-autistic people also struggle to “read” the feelings of autistic people. One study even found that non-autistic people often misinterpret autistic facial expressions as negative, even when the person is feeling calm or happy.
So if both people are misreading each other’s feelings, it’s easy to see how empathy breaks down. That’s another side of the Double Empathy Problem.
Different Ways of Showing Emotion
Another part of this puzzle is how people express their feelings. Not everyone shows emotions in the same way.
- Some people cry easily. Others go quiet.
- Some people wave their arms around when excited. Others might stim by tapping or rocking.
- Some smile automatically. Others have what’s called a “neutral affect” – a face that looks calm even when they’re feeling strong emotions inside.
In several studies, autistic and non-autistic people reported feeling similar emotions, but looked very different on the outside. That’s important. If someone assumes that emotions always look a certain way, they might totally miss what another person is experiencing.
This is especially tricky in group settings. When people interact in groups (instead of just one-on-one), things like facial expressions, tone, timing, and movement patterns become even more important. But again, those patterns aren’t universal. They’re shaped by our brains, our personalities, our cultures, and even whether we’re comfortable with the people around us.
The Bigger Picture: Rewriting the Narrative
All of this – from communication preferences to empathy to group interactions – paints a very different picture than the one we’ve been told for years.
Instead of viewing neurodivergent people as “broken” or “deficient” in social skills, we can start to see that they often just have different styles of socializing. Styles that work really well, especially when others understand and respect them.
No masking, no translating, no pretending. Friendships that feel real. Communication flows.
Optional Journal/Discussion Questions
- Have you ever felt misunderstood even when you were trying your best to communicate? What do you think caused the misunderstanding?
- What are some of your personal communication preferences? (For example: Do you like texting more than talking? Do you need time to think before responding?)
- Can you think of a time when someone else communicated differently than you expected? How did that affect the interaction?
- What are some ways we can build bridges when people have different communication styles?
- After learning about the Double Empathy Problem, how might you approach social interactions differently – with friends, classmates, or family members?
Optional Activity: Play Gartic Phone with Friends
Gartic Phone is a free online game that combines drawing, storytelling, and often a lot of laughter. It’s a great way to see how messages change as they move through different people, and how easily misunderstandings can happen (even when everyone’s trying their best).
How to Play:
- Gather a group of friends. You’ll need at least 4 people, but the more, the better!
- Go to garticphone.com and click “Start”.
- One person hosts the game and shares the game link with the others.
- Choose a game mode (the classic mode is a great place to start).
- Each player writes a silly or creative sentence to begin.
- Players take turns drawing what they think the sentence means, then guessing what someone else’s drawing represents.
- At the end, everyone sees the full chain of how the message changed from start to finish!
Why This Activity Matters:
As you play, notice how easy it is for messages to shift, even with people you know well. It’s a fun way to reflect on how communication styles, assumptions, and interpretations shape the way we understand each other.
Want to go deeper? After the game, talk about:
- What kinds of misunderstandings were funny?
- Did any drawings or guesses surprise you?
- How might this game connect to real-life communication between people who think differently?
Go Deeper/Resources
Understanding Social Cognition in Autism | Diverse Intelligences | Stories of Impact
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xZcLW64hNCs
Autism Researchers’ Rapport Study Refutes Social-Deficit Model
https://news.utdallas.edu/health-medicine/autism-rapport-study-2025/
Diversity in Social Intelligence Replication Project
https://salvesen-research.ed.ac.uk/our-projects/diversity-in-social-intelligence-replication
Autistic peer-to-peer information transfer is highly effective
https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/1362361320919286
PDF: AdaptEds Neurodiversity Affirming Handbook
Posted in Cognitive Diversity, Social Cognition


Classes
Blog posts often have a corresponding class or workshop.
Subscribe
Subscribe to the blog for interesting information about cognitive diversity from Michelle’s research and classes.
Related Posts
Self-Disclosure: A Guide for Deep Thinkers
Posted in Social Cognition, Social and Emotional Learning
Research suggests that many high-ability learners, even those who feel confident in their abilities and academic strengths, tend to share less about themselves with others. In a study …
Handling Constructive Criticism
Posted in Social Cognition, Social and Emotional Learning
Opening Quotes “Sometimes when you innovate, you make mistakes. It is best to admit them quickly, and get on with improving your other innovations.” – Steve Jobs “The …