An Odd Opening Thought: Don’t Be a Donkey

Once upon a thought experiment, a donkey stood exactly halfway between a pile of hay and a bucket of water. Hungry and thirsty in equal measure, he simply… couldn’t decide. Hay or water? Water or hay? He looked left. He looked right. He hesitated. He froze. And eventually he passed away. Of both hunger and thirst.

This is Buridan’s Donkey, a 14th-century philosophical tale used to illustrate the dangers of indecision in the face of equally important choices. It may seem extreme or even a little silly, but it’s not so far off from what happens when we freeze up before a big test or essay. The pressure mounts. You’re overwhelmed by options, expectations, and what-ifs. So instead of moving forward, you stall.

And while your test or looming essay won’t actually lead to starvation or dehydration, being stuck in a loop of avoidance, perfectionism, or panic can leave you mentally and emotionally drained.

Here’s the good news: There are strategies to help you get unstuck, manage anxiety, and take action, even when the stakes feel high.

Opening Activity: What Makes Learning Stick?

Let’s start with a quick mental challenge.

Look at the following string of letters. You have 10 seconds to memorize it. No writing it down – just look and remember:

CI AF BI KGBDN ABB CUKC NNU SA

Now, stop. Without looking back, try to recall as many of those letters as you can.

Not so easy, right?

Okay, now take a look at this version. Again, give yourself 10 seconds to memorize:

CIA FBI KGB DNA BBC UK CNN USA

Much easier?

What changed?

Absolutely nothing, except how the letters were grouped. When you see familiar patterns (like known acronyms), your brain taps into existing knowledge. Suddenly, those random strings become meaningful chunks. This is called “chunking,” and it’s a powerful strategy your memory loves.

This example comes from Scott Barry Kaufman’s Ungifted, where he explores how intelligence and learning are more about how you process information than how much you can cram in at once.

And here’s where it matters to you: Whether you’re preparing for a big test, writing an essay, or reviewing vocabulary, your success doesn’t come from raw brain power – it comes from strategy.

This Is Only a Test!

The more anxious your brain becomes, the more it defaults to logical and linear thinking. Unfortunately, when you’re anxious, what you often need is a creative solution—precisely the kind of thinking anxiety tends to block.

For this reason and often many others, gifted and twice-exceptional students may feel like explorers sent into the wilds of testing and writing armed with nothing but a pencil and mounting anxiety. 

Compass Check: Know Your Terrain

Gifted ≠ Always Easy. 2e ≠ Broken.

Before you start worrying about test scores or essay grades, get clear on who you are as a learner. Gifted and 2e students can face:

  • Asynchrony – Your ideas outpace your hands, or your logic outpaces your vocabulary.
  • Sensory Sensitivity – The wrong tag or flickering light can hijack your focus.
  • Rigid Thinking – A “creative” prompt with no clear steps might feel like a trap.
  • Perfectionism – One imperfect sentence? You delete the whole thing.
  • Executive Function Struggles: Planning, organizing, or managing time may lag behind intellectual development.

If you’re not sure what’s going on – why testing or writing feel so frustrating – it might be time to observe your own patterns or explore evaluations for learning differences. You can’t plan your route until you know the terrain.

In testing situations, these challenges become magnified by time limits, unfamiliar settings, or the pressure of performance – all of which can trigger anxiety and freeze up mental resources just when they’re needed most.

Strategies for Testing Success

1. Create Predictability to Reduce Anxiety

Tests often feel threatening because they combine performance with uncertainty. Reduce that uncertainty by gathering as much information as possible beforehand:

  • What’s the format of the test?
  • How is it scored?
  • Are there accommodations available?
  • What kind of questions have shown up in past exams?

For essay-based tests, practice breaking down prompts, drafting quick outlines, and managing time for each writing stage.

2. Adapt the Environment Where You Can

Small discomforts can become major distractions for neurodiverse students, especially those with sensory sensitivities. Plan ahead:

  • Wear familiar, comfortable clothing.
  • Bring layers to adjust to room temperature.
  • If eligible, request a quiet space or extended time under a 504 Plan or IEP.
  • Make sure you’ve planned out your basic needs for the day (rest, food, water)

These sound simple, but they are legitimate tools to help students access their full abilities under pressure.

3. Practice With Purpose

Many students avoid practice tests because they’re frustrating. But that frustration is exactly where learning happens. Research on “desirable difficulties” (Bjork, 1994) shows that effective learning often feels hard in the moment but pays off long-term.

Key strategies:

  • Space out study sessions instead of cramming.
  • Quiz yourself or teach someone else the material.
  • Mix up the order and format of review questions.
  • Simulate test conditions: time yourself, work without notes, minimize distractions.

These forms of practice build memory strength and reduce the shock factor on test day.

Below are some solid practice resources to help you build confidence with the SAT and ACT. Don’t be like Buridan’s donkey. Don’t end up doing nothing! Try both early so you can make a clear choice when it matters. I know several students who have successfully experimented with these resources years before taking the real tests.

SAT

https://www.khanacademy.org/test-prep/sat

https://magoosh.com/hs/sat/sat-practice-test/

https://www.kaptest.com/sat/free/sat-20-minute-workout

ACT

https://www.khanacademy.org/test-prep/act

https://www.act.org/content/act/en/domain-redirect-prep.html

Writing Effectively and Efficiently Under Pressure

Though the SAT and ACT have officially retired their essay components – the SAT essay was discontinued in 2021, and the ACT Writing Test is now optional and increasingly uncommon – timed essay writing is far from obsolete.

Many students still encounter timed essays in advanced coursework, entrance exams for specialized programs, writing competitions, or school-based assessments. Some private high schools and select college programs may also continue to emphasize in-person essay writing as a measure of readiness. And for neurodiverse students, these moments often expose a tension between intellectual depth and written output.

What looks like avoidance or procrastination is often something else entirely. These students may be deeply capable thinkers who struggle to perform in fast-paced, high-pressure writing settings due to:

  • Asynchrony – Complex thoughts outpace writing mechanics
  • Conceptual overload – Difficulty translating abstract ideas into timed responses
  • Rigid thinking – Uncertainty around open-ended or interpretive prompts
  • Perfectionism – Fear of writing the “wrong” sentence stalls momentum
  • Disengagement – Low interest in uninspired or formulaic topics
  • Undiagnosed learning challenges – Output issues rooted in ADHD, dysgraphia, or executive dysfunction

Timed Essays Need Structure, Not Speed

Students often benefit from demystifying the writing process. Especially under time constraints, structure offers a sense of control and direction. A repeatable and predictable writing routine can help students enter “writing mode” more efficiently so they can execute key components of the writing process (listed below):

  • Brainstorm: Jot down key ideas without worrying about wording
  • Plan: Draft a quick outline to organize the response
  • Draft: Get thoughts on the page without judging them
  • Revise: Clarify and adjust ideas for flow
  • Edit: Save mechanics and polish for the end

Even a minute or two at each stage can dramatically improve both performance and confidence.

Support Output, Not Just Insight

Timed writing is not always a test of thinking. It’s often a test of translation. If a student’s output is the bottleneck, consider supportive tools and accommodations:

  • Speech-to-text apps or dictation software
  • Typing instead of handwriting when permitted
  • Pre-writing verbally before writing begins

These tools allow students to focus on articulating ideas rather than wrestling with form. Pursue your options. Some students may even qualify for extended time.

Make the Task Feel Worthwhile

Many neurodiverse students disengage when the prompt feels too generic or irrelevant. While not every assignment can be customized, giving students room to reinterpret a prompt in a way that’s intellectually stimulating can make a difference:

  • Reframe the prompt as a debate, analogy, or real-world application
  • Look for a choice in format (persuasive, narrative, analytical)
  • Encourage personal voice or curiosity-driven responses when appropriate

Timed writing doesn’t have to be a creative constraint. For some students, it becomes manageable – or even rewarding – when the task feels like it matters and they keep a portfolio over time to see their progress.

Rethink What “Success” Looks Like

One low test score or one stalled essay does not define a student’s worth. In fact, helping students reframe their academic story may be the most important tool of all. Tests like the ACT and SAT can be taken multiple times, offering valuable opportunities to learn and improve with each attempt.

Build a Confidence Archive

Keep a visible record of academic successes:

  • High scores
  • Creative projects
  • Insightful questions
  • Compliments from teachers

Reviewing these before a test can help ground students in their strengths.

Conclusion: Think Strategically

Testing is just one piece of a puzzle – not a referendum on intelligence or potential. Even the most capable minds need scaffolding and practice tests. For all people, anxiety typically narrows thinking; strategy opens it. By understanding the challenges behind performance issues and building personalized approaches, students can move from avoidance to action and from perfectionism to progress.

Remember – this is only a test. It doesn’t measure your creativity, your character, or your capacity to grow. 

Optional Journal/Discussion Questions

  1. When have you felt like Buridan’s donkey – stuck between two equally important options – and how did it affect your ability to act?
  2. Which description in the “Compass Check” section (asynchrony, perfectionism, sensory sensitivity, etc.) felt most true to your experience as a learner?
  3. What would it mean to you if you saw tests as a challenge to manage – not a verdict on your intelligence or potential?
  4. How can you build your own “confidence archive”? What would you include in it right now?
  5. What’s one lesson from above you want to remember the next time you’re stressed about a test or essay?

Go Deeper/Resources

Book: Ungifted by Scott Barry Kaufman

Book: The Organized Mind: Thinking Straight in the Age of Information Overload by Daniel Levitin (writing efficiently is covered on pages 312 and 313)

https://www.brainbalancecenters.com/blog/test-taking-tips-for-twice-exceptional-students

Zepeda, C. D., Martin, R. S., & Butler, A. C. (2020). Motivational strategies to engage learners in desirable difficulties. Journal of Applied Research in Memory and Cognition, 9(4), 468–474.

https://my.cgu.edu/writing-rhetoric/wp-content/uploads/sites/9/2022/06/CGU-CWR-Writing-Under-Pressure-Handout.pdf

https://www.davidsongifted.org/gifted-blog/reluctant-writers-understanding-common-issues-for-gifted-children/

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4PgEIlewf7Y

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6pbcGOGKU4w



Classes

Blog posts often have a corresponding class or workshop.

Subscribe

Subscribe to the blog for interesting information about cognitive diversity from Michelle’s research and classes.

Loading

Related Posts

Analogous Thinking

At its core, analogical thinking is one of the most powerful tools for creative problem solving. What Is Analogical Thinking? Analogical thinking is the ability to use knowledge …

Handling Multipotentiality: Are You Passionate and/or Good at Several Things?

Guiding Questions What is multipotentiality and what does it have to do with high achievement? In what ways is multipotentiality like having a large menu to choose from, …