“It is easier to try to be better than you are than to be who you are.” – Marion Woodman
“There is something of a civil war going on within all of our lives. There is a recalcitrant South of our soul revolting against the North of our soul. And there is this continual struggle within the very structure of every individual life.” – Martin Luther King, Jr.
Imposter syndrome is characterized by feelings of inauthenticity despite demonstrated competence. In order to understand the complexities of imposter syndrome among academically talented students, it’s crucial to dissect the contributing factors that amplify these feelings of inadequacy.
This article addresses the specific impact of participation in honors programs and the pervasive influence of perfectionism on fostering imposter feelings. When I present on this topic, I have an engaging slide-show that breaks apart the following study and exposes students to academic research: Perfectionism and the Imposter Phenomenon in Academically Talented Undergraduates.
Study Findings
There is an increased understanding regarding the importance of supporting the complex social-emotional needs of academically talented students in order to increase their mental well-being, prevent them from opting out of honors programs, and decrease their college dropout rates.
The selected study above shows how varieties of perfectionism – socially prescribed, self-oriented, and other-oriented – compound imposter syndrome challenges, setting unrealistic standards and perpetuating self-doubt.
Previous studies have highlighted how high-achieving students who attribute their success to luck struggle with perfectionistic tendencies, which can exacerbate imposter syndrome. Research was needed to extend these insights in order to specifically examine the unique context of honors programs and their impact on imposter phenomenon.
Drawing from previous research (Bandura, 1994; Clance & Imes, 1978; Hewitt & Flett, 1991), which links perfectionism and self-worth to achievement, the examined study contributes to the understanding of different forms of perfectionism on psychological challenges faced by high-achieving students.
Findings of the study indicate that socially prescribed perfectionism, as opposed to self-oriented perfectionism or other-oriented perfectionism, and enrollment in honors programs are significantly associated with heightened imposter feelings (Lindsay Ellis Lee et al., 2020).
Different Kinds of Perfectionism
Self-oriented perfectionism checklist:
- If I screw up or fall short, I’m hard on myself.
- I hold myself to an exceptionally high standard.
- If I do not appear or perform perfectly, I feel a lot of guilt and shame.
- I strive to be perfect.
Socially prescribed perfectionism checklist:
- When I slip up or fall short, people are right there waiting to criticize me.
- Everyone else is perfect and they’re judging me if I’m not perfect, too.
- Those close to me will accept nothing less than perfection.
- People tend to get upset with me if I don’t do things perfectly.
- Everybody expects me to be perfect.
Other-oriented perfectionism checklist:
- I find it difficult to tolerate substandard performances from those around me.
- If people aren’t trying their absolute hardest, I let them know.
- Everyone should totally excel at things that are important to them.
- When someone close to me screws up or falls short, it’s important to call them out.
- I dislike being surrounded by people who’ve got low standards.
Socially Prescribed Perfectionism on the Rise
In a study involving 41,641 college students from the United States, Canada, and Britain, Thomas Curran, PhD, from the University of Bath, and Andrew Hill, PhD, from York St John University observed a 33% rise in socially prescribed perfectionism scores between 1989 and 2016.
Luckily, by implementing practical strategies such as promoting a growth mindset, normalizing failure, and cultivating supportive environments through mentorship and skills development, educators and institutions can actively mitigate the effects of socially prescribed perfectionism and imposter phenomenon while nurturing student well-being effectively.
Go Deeper/Resources
Book (for adults): The Perfection Trap: Embracing the Power of Good Enough by Thomas Curran
Article: Prediction of Imposter Syndrome in Gifted Female Students based on Ego Development, Self-efficacy, and Self-awareness: https://www.behavsci.ir/article_180160_07363ee80f3435d533b7a0e3cfeb3dba.pdf
Article: Twice-Exceptional Childhood Experiences Contributing to Imposter Syndrome in Post-secondary Faculty: https://scholarworks.waldenu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=15043&context=dissertations
Podcast: What You Still Don’t Understand About Imposter Syndrome
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KA_tuIbke64
Podcast: How to shake impostor syndrome
Posted in Social and Emotional Learning


Classes
Blog posts often have a corresponding class or workshop.
Subscribe
Subscribe to the blog for interesting information about cognitive diversity from Michelle’s research and classes.
Related Posts
Self-Disclosure: A Guide for Deep Thinkers
Posted in Social Cognition, Social and Emotional Learning
Research suggests that many high-ability learners, even those who feel confident in their abilities and academic strengths, tend to share less about themselves with others. In a study …
Handling Constructive Criticism
Posted in Social Cognition, Social and Emotional Learning
Opening Quotes “Sometimes when you innovate, you make mistakes. It is best to admit them quickly, and get on with improving your other innovations.” – Steve Jobs “The …